Case 01 – PVC Wire Wrapping Film: Formula and Production Control Failure
Share
# Case 01 – PVC Wire Wrapping Film: Formula and Production Control Failure
**Product:** PVC Wire Wrapping Film
**Destination Market:** Indonesia
**Application:** Machine wrapping for wire and cable production
## 1. What Happened
In the second batch supplied to our Indonesian customer, some rolls developed wrinkles and experienced breakage during machine application.
The customer reported that machine settings, tension and guide rollers remained unchanged.
After reviewing the production process, we identified several factors that contributed to the problem.
## 2. What Went Wrong
1. Insufficient Quality Control Before the Chinese New Year
The order was produced close to the Chinese New Year holiday, when our production schedule was tight.Production was moving too quickly, and quality monitoring was not sufficiently thorough. As a result, some production issues were not detected before shipment.
**2. Incorrect Formula Adjustment for the Destination Climate**
We changed the product formula for the second batch without adequately considering the customer's actual operating environment in Indonesia.
Indonesia has a tropical climate with high temperatures throughout the year. The adjusted formula was more suitable for certain subtropical and temperate conditions.
We failed to properly evaluate whether the new formula was suitable for the customer's local climate and application conditions.




**3. Improper Jumbo Roll Alignment During Production**
At the beginning of production, the operator did not properly align and correct the jumbo roll before starting the process.
This resulted in wrinkles in the finished film, particularly in the section closer to the core.
Our production procedures and supervision should have prevented this from happening.
## 3. Customer Impact
Fortunately, the customer had sufficient safety stock, so their production was not interrupted.
However, the quality issue caused additional costs, inconvenience and product handling work for the customer.
4. Our Responsibility
We acknowledged that the problems originated from our production and quality control processes.
We took responsibility for the incident and compensated the customer for:
- The full value of the affected products.
- Import customs clearance charges.
- International freight costs.
- Local warehousing costs.
We also arranged for the affected products to be returned.
We believe that when a quality problem is caused by our production, we should take responsibility for the actual costs incurred by our customer.
## 5. Corrective Actions
Following this incident, we made the following adjustments:
- Returned to the formula used in the first successful batch.
- Reviewed formula selection with greater consideration for destination climate and actual application conditions.
- Strengthened quality monitoring during production, especially during peak production periods.
- Reinforced jumbo roll alignment and correction procedures before production starts.
- Improved finished-roll inspection, with greater attention to winding consistency and wrinkles.
## 6. What We Learned
This incident taught us several important lessons.
Product specifications alone do not guarantee satisfactory performance. A formula that works under one set of conditions may not perform the same way in another climate or production environment.
Production pressure must never replace proper quality control.
Most importantly, we must consider not only how a product is made, but also where and how it will be used.
We made mistakes in this order, and we take responsibility for them. We have used this experience to improve our production procedures and product assessment.
7. Follow-up & Verification
After returning to the formula used in the first successful batch, we supplied several more containers to the same customer.
The customer has used these subsequent shipments in their actual production environment, and the products have performed normally.
This confirmed that returning to the previously successful formula was the right decision for this customer's application conditions.
We continue to pay attention to formula selection, production control and product performance in the customer's actual operating environment.